Papa's Subs & Pizza Holly Springs

511 North Main St, Holly Springs NC 27540

Order online

Papa's Subs & Pizza Holly Springs

511 North Main St Holly Springs, NC 27540

First pizzeria in Holly Springs. Serving New York-Style Pizza since 1995!

Pepperoni Supreme Pizza

$14.99

Add to order
Gyro Pizza

$14.99

Add to order
Supreme Pizza

$14.99

Add to order

Specials
- Large 2 + 2 + 2 Deal
  
  $26.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  2 pizzas with 2 toppings each & a 2-liter drink.
- X-Large 2 + 2 + 2 Deal
  
  $29.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  2 pizzas with 2 toppings each & a 2-liter drink.
- XX-Large 2 + 2 + 2 Deal
  
  $32.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  2 pizzas with 2 toppings each & a 2-liter drink.
- Home Alone Deal
  
  $19.79
  
  Out of stock
  
  Large pizza with 2 toppings, one liter drink & 6 wings.
- Family Meal Deal
  
  $29.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Large pizza with two toppings, 8 wings, small cheese bread & a 2-liter drink.
- The Sub Deal
  
  $23.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Two 12" subs, 2 orders of fries & two 16 oz drinks.
- Group Deal
  
  $48.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  4 large pizzas with 2 toppings each.
- Duo Wing Combo
  
  $23.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  14 Wings, 2 Fries, 2 Fountain Drinks.

Pick Up Specials

Pickup only
- Medium Pizza with One Topping
  
  $10.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Available for pick up only.
- Large Pizza with One Topping
  
  $12.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Available for pick up only.
- X-Large Pizza with One Topping
  
  $15.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Available for pick up only.
- XX-Large Pizza with One Topping
  
  $17.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Available for pick up only.
- Personal Pizza
  
  $9.25
  
  Out of stock

Pick Up Lunch Specials

Available from 11 am to 3 pm.

Available Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday 11:00 AM - 3:00 PM; Pickup only
- Calzone with One Topping & Drink
  
  $9.25
  
  Out of stock
- Stromboli with One Topping & Drink
  
  $9.25
  
  Out of stock
- 8" Sub with Fries & Drink
  
  $9.25
  
  Out of stock
- 1 Topping 10" Pizza & Drink
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock

Sunday-Thursday Pick Up Special

Available Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Sunday 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM; Pickup only
- 2 Large 1 Topping Pizzas Pick Up Special
  
  $19.99
  
  Out of stock

Pizzas
- Build Your Pizza
  
  $12.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
- Supreme Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, sausage, ham, onion, green pepper, mushroom & black olive.
- Meat Supreme Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon & beef.
- Pepperoni Supreme Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Triple pepperoni & double mozzarella
- Tenderloin Steak Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Grilled steak, green pepper, onion & mushrooms.
- Grilled Chicken Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Grilled chicken cooked with onion, mushroom & green pepper.
- Hawaiian Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Ham, Bacon & pineapple.
- Gyro Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Gyro, onion, mushroom & red Sauce.
- Taco Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Nachos, taco sauce, taco ground beef, jalapeño, cayenne pepper.
- Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Bacon, beef, onions, tomatoes, cheddar & mozzarella cheese.

Veggie Pizza
- Veggie Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Green pepper, onion, mushroom, black olive & tomato.
- Mediterranean Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spinach, tomato, black olive, eggplant & feta cheese.
- Margarita Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, olive oil & black pepper.
- Four Cheese Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Mozzarella, Gorgonzola, feta & Parmesan cheese.
- Garden Deluxe Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Green pepper, tomato, mushroom, feta, cheddar & mozzarella cheese.

White Pizza
- Greek Classic Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Olive oil base, spinach, Kalamata olive, tomato, feta & ricotta cheese (NO red sauce).
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Ranch base, grilled chicken & bacon (NO red sauce).
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Ranch & buffalo sauce base, grilled chicken & onion (NO red sauce).
- Papa’s BBQ Chicken Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chili paste, caramelized onion, garlic & tomato.
- Spicy Ranchero
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Grilled chicken, jalapenos, onions, roasted sweet peppers, spicy buffalo sauce & mozzarella cheese.
- White Spinach Pizza
  
  $14.99
  
  Out of stock

Appetizers & Side Orders
- Cheese Bread
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
- Mozzarella Sticks
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  With marinara sauce.
- Dozen Garlic Knots
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  With marinara sauce.
- Chicken Tenders
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  With honey mustard.
- French Fries
  
  $2.95
  
  Out of stock
  
  Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
- Onion Rings
  
  $4.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  With Ranch
- Jalapeno Poppers
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Juicy jalapeno poppers breaded and filled with cheese and fried to golden perfection. Served with a side of ranch
- Mac & Cheese Bites
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
- Grape Leaves
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Grape leaves stuffed with rice and vegetables cooked with olive oil and fresh lemon juice 8 pieces with a piece of fresh lemon
- Fried Ravioli
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Golden fried ravioli stuffed with delicious cheese, Served with a side of marinara.
- Fried Mushrooms
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  12 pieces fried mushroom with ranch sauce

Salads

Garden salad base for all salads: lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, black olive, shredded cheddar cheese & 1 dressing for small & 2 dressings for large size.
- Garden Salad
  
  $4.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  A garden salad made with fresh veggies.
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  A salad made with fresh veggies and perfectly cooked chicken
- Chicken Tender Salad
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  A salad with fried chicken tenders
- Chef Salad
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Turkey, ham, roast beef And provolone cheese cut into circles placed on a fresh salad.
- Greek Salad
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, olive oil & feta cheese
- Italian Salad
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Provolone, Ham, salami & pepperoni.
- Caesar Salad
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken, Croutons, Caesar Dressing and Parmesan Cheese.
- Gyro Salad
  
  $9.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Gyro, feta cheese & mild sauce or tzatziki sauce.
- Grape leaves
  
  $6.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Grape leaves stuffed with rice and vegetables cooked with olive oil and fresh lemon juice 8 pieces with a piece of fresh lemon

Homemade Sauces
- Ranch Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Mild Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Garlic Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Honey Mustard Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Italian Dressing
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Greek Dressing
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Blue Cheese Dressing
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Hot Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Garlic Parmesan Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Balsamic Dressing
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Caesar Dressing
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Thousand Island
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock
- Marinara Sauce
  
  $0.50
  
  Out of stock

Mediterranean Menu
- Gyro Wrap
  
  $9.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken OR beef & lamb, with homemade bread, lettuce, tomato, onions, and Tzatziki sauce.
- Falafel Wrap
  
  $9.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Homemade Pita bread with Tomatoes, pickles, lettuce and homemade tahini sauce.

Wings
- Buffalo Wings
  
  $8.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  With ranch or blue cheese. 6 & 8 pieces come with 1 dressing, 12 & 20 pieces come with two dressings.
- Boneless Wings
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  With ranch or blue cheese. 6 & 8 pieces come with 1 dressing, 12 & 20 pieces come with two dressings.

Burgers
- Quarter Pound Classic Cheeseburger
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Lettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese, mayo & ketchup.
- BBQ Cheeseburger
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Lettuce, tomato, onion, American cheese & BBQ sauce.
- Chicken Burger
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Mayo, (If Spicy, Hot Sauce), Lettuce, Tomato’s ,Pickle’s & American Cheese
- Fire Burger
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Jalapeño, homemade Spicy Sauce, Spicy Mayo, lettuce, Double Cheese

Calzones
- Supreme Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, sausage, ham, onion, green pepper & mushroom.
- Meat Supreme Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon & beef.
- Veggie Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Green pepper, onion, mushroom, black olive & tomato.
- Spinach Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spinach, feta, black olive, garlic & tomato.
- Greek Classic Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spinach, feta, eggplant, garlic & tomato.
- Chicken & Broccoli Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
- Steak Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Steak, onion, mushroom & green pepper.
- Chicken Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken, onion, mushroom, green pepper.
- Meatball Parmesan Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Meatballs, Green peppers, And Onions
- Buffalo Chicken Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken, buffalo sauce & ranch.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken and bacon with ranch dressing.
- Cheese Calzone
  
  $9.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Ricotta and mozzarella cheese
- Hawaiian Calzone
  
  $11.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Ham, Bacon, Pineapple, Ricotta & Mozzarella

Hot Subs

All hot subs come with mozzarella, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
- Chicken Philly Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Mushroom, sweet pepper, onion, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
- Chicken Parmesan Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken tenders, mozzarella, Parmesan, marinara sauce & oregano.
- Meatball Parmesan Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Meatballs, mozzarella, Parmesan, marinara sauce & oregano.
- BBQ Chicken Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Caramelized Onion, Chicken & BBQ Sauce
- Buffalo Chicken Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken, Papa’s buffalo sauce & Ranch.
- Veggie Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Sweet pepper, banana pepper, green pepper, mushroom, black olive & pineapple.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Chicken, Bacon, Homemade Ranch Sauce And Provolone Cheese.
- Steak Burger Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Philly Steak, Onion, Ketchup, Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato & American Cheese
- Philly Cheese Steak
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Classic Papa's Philly steak with Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mushrooms & Green Pepper

Cold Subs

All cold subs come with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, mayo, oil & vinegar, salt, pepper & oregano.
- Papa's Supreme Sub
  
  $8.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, salami, ham, turkey, roast beef & provolone.
- Italian Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Pepperoni, salami, ham & provolone.
- Club Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Turkey, ham, roast beef & provolone.
- Ham & Provolone Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
- Turkey & Provolone Sub
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
- BLT Special
  
  $7.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Provolone Cheese

Gourmet Pastas
- Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce
  
  $9.75
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spaghetti tossed in our homemade tomato sauce. serve with 3pieces, garlic knots
- Spaghetti with Meatballs
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spaghetti topped in our homemade meatballs. serve with the 3 garlic knots
- Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spaghetti tossed in homemade meat sauce. Serve with 3 pieces, garlic knots
- Spaghetti with Chicken Parmesan
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  Spaghetti, chicken, marinara sauce, cheese, mozzarella, parmesan, oregano. Serve with the three 3, garlic knots
- Stuffed Shells
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  Classic ricotta stuffed shells with flavorful three cheese ricotta filling and delicious marinara sauce. serve with the 3 pieces, garlic knots
- Meat Lasagna
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  Lasagna topped with classic cheese, tomato sauce, and ground beef. surf with the 3pieces of garlic knots
- Ziti Pasta
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  A tasty pasta cooked with beef with marinara sauce and topped with cheesy mozzarella cheese baked in the oven. serve with the 3 pieces, garlic knots
- Alfredo Chicken Pasta
  
  $10.49
  
  Out of stock
  
  Creamy chicken alfredo, with delicious garlic knots.

Desserts
- Chocolate Cake
  
  $3.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  A Creamy And Sugary chocolate Dessert
- Strawberry Cheesecake
  
  $3.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Classic Strawberry cheesecake with a rich, dense, smooth, and creamy consistency.
- Cannoli
  
  $3.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.
- Tiramisú
  
  $3.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  A Scrumptious Chocolate Italian Dessert

Kids Menu
- Nuggets meal
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Nugget (6), fries, juice and dressing of choice.
- Kiddie burger
  
  $5.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Kiddie Burger, fries and juice

Drinks Pick Up

Pickup only
- Fountain Soda Pick Up
  
  $1.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.

Drinks
- Soda Can
  
  $1.99
  
  Out of stock
  
  Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
- 20oz Drink
  
  $2.75
  
  Out of stock
  
  Nothing like a cold drink with your meal
- 2 Liter Bottle
  
  $3.75
  
  Out of stock
  
  Nothing Like a cold soda to go with your drink
- 1.25 Liter drink
  
  $3.25
  
  Out of stock

What customers are saying

What our customers are saying about Papa's Subs & Pizza Holly Springs.

5

2.8K Ratings

May 9, 2026

James Souder

Food was excellent as always. Highly recommend this place.